Sherri first posted the lyrics to this song on her Xanga site, and a demo version was used on a Boyd-produced video of the band released around Christmastime 2003. The original version used only Sherri's vocals and keyboards, while the final recording adds some subtle guitars and bass as well as rhythm and Stacy's harmonies. The remix, a bonus track on Room Noises, adds a mellow techno feel.

Also, the second verse of the original included "But the sea green is set so beautifully / Against your pallid face / That I must close my eyes and turn away," but those lyrics were changed for the version on Room Noises.

Sailing over wave and tide, oh
Fantastic waves against the sides of the hull
And I'm not so afraid, lost at sea, as I should be
And I'm not so afraid, lost at sea, you and I, you and me

Congratulations 'cause we made it
All the way home, all the way home
And you know that until the stars fall
I will always love you, I will always love you

The mystery of salt and sea, oh
Has never been intriguing, oh
To me, but the sea green is set so beautifully
Against your thoughtful face that I must close my eyes
Or turn my face

Congratulations 'cause we made it
All the way home, all the way home
And you know that until the stars fall
I will always love you, I will always love you

Still floating soft
I am dreaming, and I'm glad I'm lost
And still
With my fingers drawing circles
In water, in water
And still, still you're always there

Congratulations 'cause we made it
All the way home, all the way home
And you know that until the stars fall
I will always love you, I will always love you